Syfy's 'Sharknado 3' Fails At Being Really Good Bad Television

Jul 22, 2015
Originally published on July 22, 2015 5:12 pm

For connoisseurs of wonderfully bad television, there is a fine line between stuff that's so bad it's great fun to watch and stuff that's just bad.

And Syfy's latest Sharknado movie — the third one based on tornadoes filled with killer sharks terrorizing America, if you can believe it — has finally, unfortunately, fallen into that last category.

It's not that Sharknado 3: Oh Hell No! lives down to its title by casting spectacularly wooden Shark Tank star Mark Cuban as the president and a perpetually complaining Ann Coulter as his vice president. Or that the king of C-list celebrity David Hasselhoff, shows up as the crusty, estranged father of Ian Ziering's hero, Fin Shepard.

That's the stuff we fans of great bad television love.

No, the real sign that Sharknado 3 is beating a dead horse — or shark — into a fine paste is the fact that none of this feels fresh, new or remotely funny anymore.

Consider the cameo appearances from the top four anchors at NBC's Today show, who treat a storm that buffeted Washington, D.C., with all the seriousness of a terrorist attack.

"The Washington Monument, the White House, not far from where we are right now ... both destroyed by the worst sharknado this country has seen since the first formation two years ago," Today host Matt Lauer says. But since we've seen this act twice before, it mostly looks like product placement for Syfy's corporate parent, NBCUniversal.

This won't necessarily bother Syfy or NBCUniversal, which seem to be counting on Sharknado to repeat its past success as a buzzed-about topic on Twitter and other social media. In anticipation of renewed attention, the film is packed with corporate siblings like Universal Studios theme parks, Xfinity online services, Comcast cable and more.

Even Ziering, who has turned playing hyper-focused disaster movie hero Fin Shepard into a deadpan art, can't save this one. Not when he's forced to explain to President Cuban — ugh — why he thinks the Sharknado that devastated the nation's capitol was just a start.

"I know how this is going to sound, but I can sense these storms now," he says, intensely. "These sharks have a scent, and it's not a pretty one."

Neither is the smell of this movie, which has the distinct aroma of a joke repeated a few too many times.

Such spoof films are pretty much critic-proof — how can you criticize a movie that's basically an intentionally unintentional comedy?

This is also part of a trend. Syfy has been making B-movie disaster films for a while now. In the Sharknado series, they've found that turning into the skid of bad acting and low budgets on these projects can bring even more attention, and other cable channels have noticed.

Lifetime let Will Ferrell make A Deadly Adoption; an essentially straight film about a successful couple who take in a pregnant woman with hopes of adopting her baby only to see her turn into a dangerous psycho. It was a note-perfect recreation of the channel's actual women-in-peril movies, made awkward by the fact that the actors played it too straight to generate many laughs.

Ferrell also has made miniseries spoofs for IFC — The Spoils of Babylon and The Spoils Before Dying — that were packed with big names like Haley Joel Osment and Tobey Maguire playing melodramatic roles pretty straight. Even some of Lifetime's ostensibly serious movies like its Unauthorized Saved by the Bell Story seem built more to draw laughs from the audience than anything.

These projects make sense for the cable channels. They draw media coverage and pull in viewers who would normally make fun of the channel's more serious fare, bringing a new dimension to their audience.

But that tactic doesn't work so well if the movie in question isn't fun to watch, even ironically.

And that's where the latest Sharknado really fails, leaving some fans of awful TV to wonder what we truly found so funny about shark-filled tornadoes in the first place.

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:

Imagine a world where eccentric billionaire Mark Cuban is president of the United States. And imagine during his administration, tornadoes filled with man-eating sharks hit the eastern seaboard. All that happens tonight on Syfy's disaster movie parody, "Sharknado 3: Oh Hell No!" NPR TV critic Eric Deggans says this one is truly a disaster.

ERIC DEGGANS, BYLINE: What's the first sign that Syfy's latest "Sharknado" movie is a dead horse beaten into a fine paste? The fact that appearances from NBC's "Today" show crew talking about tornadoes filled with man-eating sharks doesn't really seem that unusual anymore.

(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "SHARKNADO 3: OH HELL NO!")

MATT LAUER: (As himself) I'm Matt Lauer along with Savannah Guthrie, the "Today" show reporting live now. The Washington Monument, the White House, not far from where we are right now, both destroyed by the worst sharknado this country has seen since the first formation two years ago.

DEGGANS: Fans of Syfy's aggressively awful disaster flick knows this means one thing. Ian Ziering's aptly named hero, Fin Shepard, is back in the thick of it. In a country filled with science guys and brainiacs, he's the only one who can really predict the ways of the sharknado. At least, that's what he tells the nation's president, Mark Cuban.

(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "SHARKNADO 3: OH HELL NO!")

IAN ZIERING: (As Fin Shepard) D.C. isn't safe.

MARK CUBAN: (As U.S. President) What?

ZIERING: (As Fin Shepard) I know how this is going to sound, but I can sense these storms now - the drop in temperature, the humidity, these crazy cloud formations. These sharks, they have a scent, and it's not a pretty one.

DEGGANS: Neither is the scent of this movie, which has the distinct aroma of a joke repeated way too often. Now, to be fair, it has all the stuff that made the first two "Sharknados" such absurd, so-bad-it's-fun-to-watch entertainment. There's the gobbledygook explanations for how sharks survive in a tornado.

(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "SHARKNADO 3: OH HELL NO!")

UNIDENTIFIED ACTRESS: (As character) But sharknado sharks, they eat something that regular sharks don't, birds.

DEGGANS: And there's the stunt casting of B- and C-level celebrities like David Hasselhoff and Ann Coulter, who plays the vice president.

(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "SHARKNADO 3: OH HELL NO!")

UNIDENTIFIED ACTRESS: (As character) What's your opinion of these shark storms, Madam Vice President?

ANN COULTER: (As U.S. Vice President) I feel for the sharks, but they're wrecking our schools, our hospitals, our roads.

DEGGANS: I won't say if she gets eaten by a shark or not. There's a fine line between movies that are so stupid they're fun to watch and movies that are just plain stupid. And "Sharknado 3: Oh Hell No!" proves even the dumbest fun can be ruined if you just tell the same lame joke over and over and over again. That won't bother Syfy or its owner, NBC Universal. Last year, "Sharknado's" sequel became the channel's most-watched original movie ever. It drew nearly 4 million viewers and one billion Twitter impressions. And that's one reason other cable channels have tried making fun of themselves with their own parody movies.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

DEGGANS: For instance, Lifetime's aptly titled film "A Deadly Adoption" featured Will Ferrell and Kristen Wiig. The two comic actors played it mostly straight as a couple who take in a pregnant woman who turns out to be a murderous psycho. Here, Ferrell is telling police their guest may have kidnapped their child.

(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "A DEADLY ADOPTION")

WILL FERRELL: (As Robert Benson) Have you issued some sort of alert? Are you putting up a roadblock?

KRISTEN WIIG: (As Sarah Benson) She's pregnant, and we're adopting her baby. We actually know very little about her. She seems very nice. I'm sure this is just a misunderstanding.

DEGGANS: Though it was kind of boring, "A Deadly Adoption" was the highest-rated original show on cable the night it aired. These kinds of movies, including "Sharknado 3," make sense for cable channels seeking more media coverage and a new audience. But in "Sharknado's" case, Syfy's crafted a new installment that's a pale echo of the earlier versions, leaving fans to wonder what was really so funny the first time around. I'm Eric Deggans. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.