Discouraged In Hunt For A Job, Many Stop Looking
The U.S. population is growing. In normal times, the labor force — working or not — would be growing too. But these are not normal times, and the labor force is actually smaller than it was four years ago, meaning millions of people who should be there aren't.
The reasons people drop out of the workforce are myriad. People go back to school. Others have health issues or family priorities that keep them from looking for work. But some stop looking because they are discouraged.
'Discouraged' is not just a state of mind. It's an official term the Labor Department uses to describe the 844,000 people who last month had given up on trying to find a job because they didn't think there was anything out there for them. So while the unemployment rate edged down this month, there are also more people who have quit sending out resumes, put their best suits back in the closet and stopped looking for work altogether.
Retirement And Its Malcontents
Both Geoff Dutton and his wife, a neuroscientist, have Ph.D.'s. But for years now, neither has found work. Dutton spent years writing software manuals. At 68, he says he can't afford to retire, yet finding a job also feels out of reach.
"My skills were beginning to slip away," Dutton says. "I wasn't up on the new version of everything anymore. Software was turning to the cloud and the Web. The companies that were in that area kept looking for people who had been in that area, and that wasn't me."
Discouraged workers like Dutton aren't the only ones not in the job market anymore, but there's little conclusive information about who these people are, or what they're doing instead.
"It really looks like people are limping across the finish line to retirement," says Courtney Coile, an economist at Wellesley College who studies older workers.
For some, dropping out of the labor force is a good sign: Their stock portfolios have recovered, and they can now retire comfortably.
But Coile says a very small percentage of labor force dropouts can claim to be so lucky. The numbers suggest less educated, long-term-unemployed people are turning elsewhere. The number of people on disability insurance has increased more than 20 percent in the past four years.
"It looks like, for some people, the disability insurance programs function as an unemployment insurance of last resort," Coile says.
School: Not Always The Best Years Of Your Life
School is another force pulling workers away from their job searching, but going back to school isn't exactly an attractive option for workers in their 50s. Nonetheless, school enrollment is increasing because of people like Lara Jones, who opted to retrain after losing her job as a contractor for Microsoft. For two years, employers told her she was underqualified for programming jobs but overqualified for supermarket work.
"I was doing all the things that they said you're supposed to do, customizing my resume to job postings," Jones says. "I was getting good feedback on my interview skills. I was doing all the things you're supposed to do, but it wasn't working."
At 44 years of age, Jones secured financial aid and enrolled in community college. Next year, she hopes to transfer to the University of Washington and become a software engineer, a skill she knows is in demand. But, she admits, it is odd being old enough to be your classmate's mother.
"I did an internship over the summer, and it's just really weird to be 44 and be an intern," Jones says. "It's just sort of uncomfortable. It's really weird when your teachers are roughly the same age that you are."
For Carol Bellows, the trade-off of going back to school in her 40s did not pay off.
"I regret going to school. I regret being in that debt. I made more money as a ballet dancer than as a landscape architect," Bellows says.
'It Feels Like You Can't Participate In Society'
Now 57, Bellows lives in Tigart, Ore. Her degree did get her a good job, but it lasted only a year.
"I got a bonus check, at Christmas," Bellows says, laughing. "All those things that I'd been hearing about for years with real jobs. And I had health insurance, and it was just truly amazing."
Since 2008, her only job has been a temporary gig with the census. Recently, she gave up looking. She says it simply made sense. Her job search took a lot of time, which meant household chores fell to her husband.
"He's actually asked me to drop the job search, and take care of things, so the rest of our life doesn't fall apart," Bellows says.
Now, Bellows says making money is not the only thing she misses.
"You can't participate in society," she says, voice full of emotion. "You can't go to the store and buy something because you can't afford to. You can't go to a firm and have a Christmas party."
Bellows says she still hopes to work again someday, but that sometimes it feels like it would be easier to win the lottery.
9(MDAwMTM1NDgzMDEyMzg2MDcwMzJjODJiYQ004))
Transcript
STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:
You may have noted the unemployment rate went down the other day, in part because so many people left the labor force - for a variety of reasons, sure, but many of them were discouraged workers. A discouraged worker doesn't just describe a state of mind. That's an official term referring to people who gave up their job searchers because they couldn't find anything. And according to the Labor Department, there were 844,000 of them last month.
The overall labor force - which in normal times grows - is actually shrinking. NPR's Yuki Noguchi reports.
YUKI NOGUCHI, BYLINE: Both Geoff Dutton and his wife, a neuroscientist, have PhDs. But for years now, neither has found work. Dutton spent years writing software manuals. At 68, he says he can't afford to retire, yet finding a job also feels out of reach.
GEOFF DUTTON: My skills were beginning to slip away. I wasn't up on the new version of everything anymore. Software was turning to the cloud and the Web. The companies that were in that area, you know, kept looking for people who had been in that area, and that wasn't me.
NOGUCHI: But discouraged workers like Dutton aren't the only ones not in the job market anymore. Because the U.S. population is growing, the pool of those working or looking for work should also be increasing. Instead, the labor force is slightly smaller than it was four years ago, meaning millions of people who should be there, aren't.
But there's little conclusive information about who these people are, or what they're doing instead. Courtney Coile is an economist at Wellesley College who studies older workers.
COURTNEY COILE: It really looks like people are limping across the finish line to retirement.
NOGUCHI: One man I interviewed in his 60s gave up looking for work after his stock portfolio recovered. But Coile says a very small percentage of labor force dropouts can claim to be so lucky. In fact, the numbers suggest less educated, long-term unemployed people are turning elsewhere.
COILE: It looks like the disability insurance programs function as a unemployment insurance of last resort.
NOGUCHI: The number of people on disability insurance has increased more than 20 percent in the last four years. Going back to school isn't an attractive option for workers in their 50s, but school enrollment is increasing, because of people like Lara Jones, who opted to retrain after losing her job as a contractor for Microsoft.
For two years, employers told her she was under qualified for programming jobs but overqualified for grocery store work.
LARA JONES: I was doing all the things they said you're supposed to do. You know, customizing your resume to job postings. I was getting good feedback on my interview skills. I was doing all the things you're supposed to do, but it wasn't working.
NOGUCHI: So, at 44 years of age, Jones secured financial aid, and enrolled in community college. Next year, she hopes to transfer to the University of Washington and become a software engineer - a skill she knows is in demand. But, she admits, it is odd being old enough to be your classmate's mom.
JONES: I did an internship over the summer, and it's just really weird to be 44 and be an intern. That's sort of uncomfortable. It's weird when your teachers are roughly the same age that you are.
NOGUCHI: For Carol Bellows, the tradeoff of going back to school in her 40s did not pay off.
CAROL BELLOWS: I regret going to school. I regret being in that debt. I made more money as a ballet dancer than as a landscape architect.
NOGUCHI: Now 57, Bellows lives in Tigard, Oregon. Her degree did get her a good job, but it only lasted a year.
BELLOWS: I got a bonus check, at Christmas.
(LAUGHTER)
BELLOWS: All those things that I'd been hearing about for years, about, you know, with real jobs. And, you know, I had health insurance, and it was just truly amazing.
NOGUCHI: Since 2008, her only job has been a temporary gig with the Census. Recently, she gave up looking. She says it simply made sense. Her job search took a lot of time, which meant household chores fell to her husband.
BELLOWS: He's actually asked me to drop the, you know, job search, and take care of things, so that the rest of our life doesn't fall apart.
NOGUCHI: Bellows says making money is not the only thing she misses.
BELLOWS: It felt like I couldn't even participate - excuse me, this is really emotional now. You can't participate in society. You can't go to the store and buy something, because you can't afford to. You can't go to a firm and have a Christmas party.
NOGUCHI: She says she still hopes to work again someday. But sometimes it feels like it would be easier to win the lottery. Yuki Noguchi, NPR News, Washington. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.